top of page

How to Be Coachable Without Losing Your Confidence

Feb 13
3 min read

Updated: Oct 5

Being coachable does not mean listening to everyone.


Be Coachable is one of my core values, and one of C-Suite Coach's. I have always prided myself on being open to feedback and looking for ways to improve.


At times, I've struggled with it. I found myself receiving feedback from people who seemed to discount how hard I had to work to "do the thing." They would critique the one thing I missed, and the achievements around it went unmentioned.


I once had a contractor working for me who put together a 20-page deck about my failures as a founder. By then I had built a multimillion-dollar business, and this person owned a business too. Some of what was in the deck may have been worth hearing. A lot of it read as personal attacks rather than criticism offered from a place of understanding.


Reading it, I felt my defenses go up. The SCARF model, developed by David Rock, describes five things we instinctively protect in our interactions with other people: status, certainty, autonomy, relatedness, and fairness. Feedback that feels personal lands directly on status. My first instinct was to protect mine by pointing to what I had accomplished and to the fact that I was the one providing the work. I noticed that I was preparing a defense and had stopped listening, which meant that even the useful parts of that deck couldn't reach me.


I share that because it happens to all of us. When feedback feels like an attack, a person's energy goes to defending themselves, and there is very little left for taking the feedback in. If you want someone to hear you, how you deliver the message matters as much as the message.


That experience also taught me something about where useful feedback comes from. Feedback from someone with similar experience can still miss, and feedback from someone without it can be exactly what you need. I see this in coaching. Many coaches have never held their client's role, and they can still be very effective, because a skilled coach asks questions, works to understand your context, and is invested in your growth. Many of the best coaches in sports never matched what their athletes accomplished. What makes feedback useful is the understanding and the intent behind it.


I realized that if I let every piece of feedback in, I would lose my confidence. If I blocked it all out, I would stop growing. I had to coach myself on how to sort it, so I could decide which feedback to internalize and which to acknowledge and move on from.


These are the questions I started asking myself.

  • Is the feedback about my work, or about me? Feedback I can use points to a decision, a behavior, or a result. When it becomes a judgment of who I am, I know my defenses will go up, and I have to work harder to find what's useful in it.

  • Do they see the full picture? Sometimes a person is critiquing a decision without knowing the financial or operational constraints behind it. When that's the case, I take the feedback with that gap in mind.

  • What is the feedback meant to do? Some feedback is offered to help me win. Some reflects what the other person would be comfortable with, which may be very different from the risk I've chosen to take.


I still treat all feedback as information. What I learned is to consider the understanding and the intent behind it before I decide how much of it to carry.


You can stay open to growth and still protect your confidence. The next time feedback knocks you off balance, you can ask yourself these three questions before you decide what to do with it.



bottom of page